The United States science and engineering community face multiple challenges related to funding and funding policies for science and engineering. A framework is needed to evaluate the impact scientific facilities and instruments. In this paper, we demonstrate such an activity through our comprehensive work evaluating the scientific impact of XSEDE using the Semantic Scholar Data. In contrast to other studies, our study includes the bibliographic references of all recorded papers related to XSEDE over the entire performance period till April of 2021. This makes this study unique and distinguishes it from our earlier work while using (a) over 180 million papers as a comparison to our peer analysis, (b) include all publications reported, and (c) conduct the study repeatedly over several years to verify its validity.
